A few months ago there was an interesting video on the subject that said that people with the belief in a soul mate had more problems in their relationships than those who weren't invested in that ideology. Makes sense. I guess their always looking for the bigger better deal.
In my opinion, a soul mate would be able to meet your needs in a wide range of areas: sexually, emotionally, intellectually, spiritually, physically, morally, socially, politically, and etc.... Is that too much to ask from one person? I mean really.
The saying opposites attract is often very true. Are they soul mates???
And look at arranged marriage cultures. In Amish, Hindu, and Orthodox Jews the divorce rate is 1,3,and 7%. Are they picking soul mates? Just because they stay together though doesn't mean they're happy either...but I'd bet plenty are.
So a few months ago I made the hypothetical example to a friend that I had everything going well with my marriage, my wife and I were on the same page with everything except religion/spirituality. Then I said, "if you and your wife had the same issue, would you mind if I met with your wife once a month to go over a bible study or go to church?" And he said that he would be fine with that. I said, "are you sure? You wouldn't feel threatened or upset that you were not fulfilling her in that area, that you two weren't on the same page?". He said, "no I'd think it was cool".
So for fun I shifted it to sex. What if everything was going great except there were some sexual things that just didn't line up perfectly but all in all it was mostly good and the same applied to you and your marriage. Would it be okay if I met up with your wife once a month in that area?? He said, "no of course not....".
So it was all a funny hypothetical, but at what point does not being enough in ALL areas of compatibility become an issue. At what point do you say that you "deserve" to be fulfilled in all the areas of your relationship? If you believe in a soul mate, then you probably think you are "settling" in a relationship if EVERYTHING isn't lined up and meeting your needs.
I am married to my best friend. Don't tell me something you don't want her to know. And vice versa. BUT, we also have a lot of areas that we differ in. We have areas that I think she goes too far and she thinks I don't go far enough. We have our share of arguments and disagreements about things.
Is there anyone out there that may be more compatible for either of us? Maybe. I guess I don't really think about that because I'm happy. I suppose that I've learned that since there are no perfect people, that would mean that there are no perfect relationships either. And so in the end maybe it comes down to this: soul mates accept each other.
I accept her and she accepts me. I "know" her and she "knows" me. And she and I STILL accept each other. I think that maybe that may be my definition of a soul mate.
Someone who knows you really and accepts you.